Case Study 7 “A Life For A Life”

Case Study 7 “A Life For A Life” Name: Complete the required categories below and then, in a thoughtful, well constructed essay of 100-250 words, answer the question: What should Manny do; Why? 1. Gather the facts: What are the objective facts to be considered in this case? 2. Determine the Ethical Issues: What are the competing interests or “goods” at issue in this case? 3. Identify the Principles: What are the principles which underscore the competing principles in this case? (Principles may be derived from whatever informs an ethical system such as scripture, church teaching, natural law, US Constitution, categorical imperative etc.) 4. List the Alternatives: Creatively consider developing alternative courses of action to the case question. 5. Compare Alternatives with Principles: Eliminate alternatives according to the moral principles which have bearing on the case. 6. Consider the Consequences: Examine remaining alternatives in light of foreseeable consequences. Remember some positive consequences are more beneficial than others and some negative consequences are more detrimental than others. 7. Make a Decision: After employing the above process, “What should Manny do; Why? Remember, often ethical dilemmas have no easy, painless solution. Your Response should be developed in an essay of 100 to 250 words.