Instruction
CSP/SOC 105
Term Paper Project Requirements
Overview
For this term paper assignment, you will investigate and report on some issue related to the course material that involves some controversy -- that is, some social, legal, or ethical aspect of computers or computing technology. If your topic is covered in the text, do not use the text as a main source. Report in more depth and/or on newer or other aspects of the topic.
How long should the term paper be? The paper should be long enough to cover the background/history of the topic, state the different sides of the issue with arguments and counter arguments, and draw your conclusions. For those who insist on a number, the paper should be approximately 3000 words in length, however, I never check the word count and it does not impact your grade at all. The grade is based entirely on the quality of your paper and how well you present the different sides of the issue as well as your conclusions. This project is to be done this semester. Do not turn in a paper done earlier for another course or for your job. If you are writing a paper on the same topic for another class this semester you must get my approval ahead of time. Your paper may check out as being plagiarized if you submit it to more than one professor.
Guidelines/Specifications for the Paper
Remember that the focus of this course is on social, legal, and ethical issues. Don't just give technical descriptions, or material that is purely factual or historic. On the other hand, be sure to give enough facts to support your opinions.
Explain how your topic relates to material covered in the text and/or in class discussions. Be sure to include an explanation of all the major course-related issues.
Your paper should also include your own analysis and evaluation (after you have presented the major arguments). Select some course-related issue about which there is controversy or disagreement. Summarize the different points of view on this issue (giving appropriate citations). The paper should cover all sides of an issue, whether you agree with the arguments or not. All arguments should be presented completely and in an unbiased manner. Then evaluate the arguments on the different sides, give counter arguments, and state and justify your own position. Be sure to support your position with convincing arguments and facts -- try to write in a way that would make someone who initially disagreed with you think about the issue more carefully.
Be sure to use a variety of reference sources (and a variety of types of sources). Include at least two resources from peer-reviewed journals (please ask if you do not know what a peer-reviewed journal is) or books. Articles from magazines and Web sites are acceptable but should not be considered as reliable as peer-reviewed journals or books. Quote where appropriate. Give citations for facts and quotations, indicating the sources for the material you are using. However, you should not just copy paragraphs from other sources. Explain the material as clearly as you can in your own words.
The organization of your paper will depend somewhat on the topic you select. However, the organization of your term paper might look like this:
NOTE: YOUR TERM PAPER SHOULD SHOW SUB-TITLES/TOPICS AS INDICATED IN THE TERP PAPER ORGANIZATION ABOVE. PLEASE DO NOT SUBMIT A TERM PAPER COMPOSED OF ONE BIG PARAGRAPH WIHTOUT SEPARATING AND INDICATING SUB-TITLE/TOPICSS OR YOUR VERSION OF THEM, AS INDICATED ABOVE.
Cover page, with title, your name and email, course and instructor
Overview of topic and issues discussed
Background, history, and/or importance of the topic
Explanation of issues related to the course material, detail arguments on all sides of the issue, include counter arguments where appropriate
Your analysis and evaluation on some issue about which there is disagreement
Summary and conclusions
List of references used and cited
Warnings and Reminders
Pay attention to the quality of your sources. If you use articles from the Web as sources, give the URL and the organization sponsoring the site. There's a lot of junk and unsupported opinion on the Web.
Plagiarism. Now and then a student hands in a paper he or she did not write at all, or in which large segments are copied from other sources. Please don't do this. It is dishonest, unfair to your fellow students, and unpleasant for both you and me. Cases of plagiarism will result in a failing grade for the course. Write in your own words. Ask me if you have any questions about what is appropriate.
Grading Criteria
Grading criteria include:
following instructions for the assignment (including submitting the title/topic description and outling)
discussion of background or history of the topic
presentation of issues related to the course material
quality of argument and analysis
structure and organization
clarity of writing
sufficient references
originality
meeting deadlines.